Not Every Gift Needs to Be Kept
The hidden discrimination in "Executive presence" and what to do about it.
"You need to work on your executive presence." What does that actually mean? I think it's an ableist catch-all, and Flo finds the term annoying. So we take it apart: who it was built for, why it gets used on people who don't fit the picture, and what Harvard Business Review's research says has changed about gravitas, communication and appearance. Then what leaders should say instead, and what to do when the feedback lands on you. Feedback is a gift. Not every gift needs to be kept.
Not Every Gift Needs to Be Kept
Follow Different at Work free in your podcast app
“Executive presence” shows up in a lot of performance reviews. It’s supposed to mean the ability to project confidence, inspire trust and influence people. In practice it often means “there’s something about you I can’t name,” and for a neurodivergent person, that something is usually just how we’re wired.
Flo calls it an annoying term. Andrew calls it an ableist one. We spend this episode figuring out what’s actually inside it, and what isn’t.
We start with the stereotype (picture Jack Donaghy from 30 Rock), and its cousins: executive maturity and culture fit. Flo has two assessments: someone who breaks the mold can feel like a threat to the people whose careers were built on fitting it, and that the friction is often about identity. Defensiveness. Jealousy. Envy. Nostalgia. Pick your word.
Then the research. Sylvia Ann Hewlett has been studying executive presence for more than a decade, and her 2024 Harvard Business Review article compares what leaders valued in 2012 with what they valued in 2022. The three pillars are the same: gravitas, communication and appearance. What’s gaining weight inside them is different: inclusiveness and respect, listening to learn, being at ease on a video call, authenticity, and dressing for the job you’re actually doing at 11 p.m. on a launch night.
Last, what to do with it, whether you give the feedback or get it.
In this episode:
- “Coaching me to my personality.” Why Andrew thinks the term is ableist, and why it ends up as the default note in a review that has nothing else to say
- The stereotype and its cousins. Executive presence, executive maturity, culture fit, and when they really mean “you’re not like us”
- Two assessments. Why a different leader can feel like a threat, and why it’s about identity, not the person
- Breaking the mold. Bozoma Saint John, bright colors, and Flo’s MAC Ruby Woo
- The new rules. Hewlett’s research: gravitas, communication and appearance, then and now. “Earning the right to be heard”
- Hoodies at the launch room, and a CEO in magenta. How dress codes and culture follow the person at the top
- Check your biases. Mental shortcuts are useful. Unchecked, they misfire. Notice the tight stomach and the snap judgment
- For leaders: say what you actually mean, ask whether it matters for the role, ask questions first, and change the environment, not just the person
- If you get the feedback: take a breath, ask for an example, triangulate, and remember that not every gift needs to be kept
Chapters
00:00 Cold open
00:16 Intro
00:33 Welcome
00:45 What "executive presence" is supposed to mean
01:22 "Coaching me to my personality": why I call it ableist
03:31 Its cousins: executive maturity and culture fit
04:55 The stereotype, starring Jack Donaghy
05:29 C-suites in T-shirts, and a maverick CEO
06:49 Bozoma Saint John, bright colors, and Ruby Woo
08:51 "Don't make the stakeholders uncomfortable"
09:10 Flo's first assessment: a threat to the old path
11:55 The second: it's about identity
12:59 Defensiveness, jealousy, envy, nostalgia
16:12 The new rules: Sylvia Ann Hewlett in HBR
16:46 Gravitas: from pedigree to respect
18:40 Communication: listen to learn, and earn the right to be heard
20:48 Appearance: realness and the new normal
21:19 Hoodies in the launch room, and bathrobe day
22:58 Poofy skirts, and widening the definition
24:52 The Uncarrier: culture follows the person at the top
26:45 Challenge your biases
29:53 Snap judgments are a red flag
30:40 Sour grapes? Why we're talking about this
32:01 For leaders: say what you actually mean
33:40 Ask questions first, and ask whether it matters
34:41 Old definitions vs. today's job
35:44 Change the environment, not just the person
37:05 If you get the feedback
38:40 Through an ADHD lens: rejection sensitivity
39:21 Wrap-up
40:37 One final note
Resources & links
From the episode
- The article. Sylvia Ann Hewlett, “The New Rules of Executive Presence,” Harvard Business Review, January–February 2024. Gravitas, communication and appearance, 2012 vs. 2022. hbr.org
- The chart. HBR’s one-page summary of what changed in each pillar. Redefining Executive Presence
- Bozoma Saint John, the executive Flo talks about: marketing at PepsiCo and Apple Music, then chief brand officer at Uber, CMO at Endeavor, and CMO at Netflix. Wikipedia
- Mental shortcuts. The classic paper on heuristics and the biases they produce. Tversky & Kahneman (1974), Science. doi.org/10.1126/science.185.4157.1124
- Biases you don’t know you have. Implicit social cognition. Greenwald & Banaji (1995). doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.102.1.4
A few clarifications
We talk fast and we don’t fact-check mid-sentence. That’s what this section is for.
- “Decades of research.” Hewlett’s executive-presence work runs from her 2012 survey to a 2022 follow-up. A decade, and a lot of interviews, not decades.
- The old rules didn’t disappear. In Hewlett’s 2022 data, confidence and decisiveness still lead gravitas, and speaking skill still leads communication. Inclusiveness, respect, listening and authenticity are what’s gaining weight. Flo said “still important” more than once; this is why.
- Is “executive presence” ableist? That’s my opinion, and I said so. The argument: when the term goes unexplained, it tends to reward traits that come more easily to neurotypical people (eye contact, quick verbal answers, a certain kind of polish) instead of the outcomes that matter for the job.
- Where bias comes from. Biases are mostly learned, from experience, culture and the people around us, and they run whether or not we notice. That’s what makes them worth checking.
- Color blindness isn’t neurodivergence. Flo’s point is broader: “executive presence” can quietly exclude anyone whose body or brain doesn’t fit a narrow picture.
- Asking questions as a manager. When I say “ask questions to get to the why,” I mean ask about the work: what’s getting in the way, what would help. Don’t ask whether someone has ADHD or any other diagnosis. In the US, the ADA limits disability-related questions to current employees, and disclosure is the employee’s choice. EEOC guidance
Something we didn’t get to
- Masking. A lot of what gets called executive presence (steady eye contact, no fidgeting, the quick confident answer) is exactly what neurodivergent people mask to produce, and masking has a cost. We talked about it in burnout; it deserves its own episode.
- Accommodations. If executive-presence feedback is really about something an accommodation could fix (processing time, written follow-ups, figures in advance), that’s a conversation with HR, not a personality flaw. EARN has the employer side. askearn.org
From us
- S1:E12, I Math Differently. The dyscalculia episode, and where “send the numbers in advance” comes from. Listen
- S1:E4, Different For Hire, Part I. Rejection sensitivity, and why feedback can land like a punch. Listen
- S1:E9, You Can’t Out-Charm Burnout. Masking and what it costs. Listen
- S1:E10, I’m Not an Executive, Why Do I Need to Function? Psychological safety and accommodations, for leaders. Listen
- S1:E11, This Is Not a Clip Show. The support scaffolding I mention: tools that help you, and the people around you. Listen
- Our Resources page: crisis lines, ADHD organizations, and more. differentatwork.com/resources
Sources
- Greenwald, A. G., & Banaji, M. R. (1995). Implicit social cognition: Attitudes, self-esteem, and stereotypes. Psychological Review, 102(1), 4–27. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.102.1.4
- Hewlett, S. A. (2024). The new rules of executive presence. Harvard Business Review, 102(1), 110–117. https://hbr.org/2024/01/the-new-rules-of-executive-presence
- Tversky, A., & Kahneman, D. (1974). Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science, 185(4157), 1124–1131. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.185.4157.1124
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (2000). Enforcement guidance on disability-related inquiries and medical examinations of employees under the ADA. https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/enforcement-guidance-disability-related-inquiries-and-medical-examinations-employees
More resources
If you need help right now
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: call or text 988, 24/7 (US). 988lifeline.org
- Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741, 24/7, free and confidential. crisistextline.org
- NAMI HelpLine: 1-800-950-NAMI (6264), or text “NAMI” to 62640. Weekdays, 10 a.m.–10 p.m. ET. Support and information, not crisis care. nami.org/help
Learning about ADHD and neurodivergence
- CHADD: evidence-based ADHD information, support groups, and advocacy. chadd.org
- Attention Deficit Disorder Association (ADDA): the largest organization focused on adults with ADHD. add.org
- Understood.org: plain-language guides to ADHD, dyslexia, dyscalculia and other kinds of neurodivergence. understood.org
- Learning Disabilities Association of America (LDA): dyscalculia and other learning disabilities, with state affiliates. ldaamerica.org
- Dr. Russell A. Barkley: free fact sheets from one of the most cited ADHD researchers. russellbarkley.org
- Dr. Thomas E. Brown: the late researcher behind the six-cluster model of executive function. His clinic continues as the Kennedy ADHD Clinic. brownadhdclinic.com
Getting support
- ADD Coach Academy (ADDCA) coach directory: find a coach trained to work with ADHD brains. addca.com
At work
- EARN (Employer Assistance and Resource Network on Disability): neurodiversity in the workplace, for employees and employers. askearn.org
We’re not mental health professionals, and we don’t endorse every resource for every person. Do your own research, and find the help that fits you. Full list: differentatwork.com/resources
One more thing
Flo would like it on the record that if MAC ever discontinues Ruby Woo, we’re gonna have a fight.
If you’re struggling
We’re not mental health professionals, and nothing in this episode replaces therapy, diagnosis, or professional care. We’re just two people sharing what we’ve lived and learned.
If you’re in crisis, call or text 988 (US, 24/7). More options are listed under More resources above.
Keep being you. Different at work.
Transcript
00:00:00 Andrew: Personally, I think it's an ableist term. That term just reminds me of performance reviews or feedback that I've gotten in the past where I feel like you're coaching me to my personality.
00:00:11 Flo: Feedback is a gift and not every gift needs to be kept.
00:00:15 ♪ Intro music ♪
00:00:33 Andrew: Hi, I'm your host, Andrew Sanders.
00:00:34 Flo: And hi, I am your co-host, Flo LaBrado.
00:00:38 Andrew: Welcome to Different at Work, where we talk navigating the modern workplace and cultivating professional relationships while being wired a little differently.
00:00:46 Flo: Today's topic is executive presence, which, to be honest, I find that term very annoying. It's supposed to be the ability to project confidence, inspire trust, and be able to influence. And the stereotype is imagine someone who's standing really tall and collected and they're nicely dressed. And when they walk into the room, you feel their presence. That's the visuals. Andrew, when you hear the term executive presence, what comes up for you?
00:01:22 Andrew: Personally, I think it's an ableist term. And I'll get to my explanation there in a second. But that term just reminds me of performance reviews or feedback that I've gotten in the past where I feel like you're coaching me to my personality. You're trying to tell me that I have a wrong personality or I need to change how I think or who I am. I understand that there are some important components of being an executive or a leader that the person using the term executive presence might be trying to convey, like the ability to inspire or motivate others through how you communicate or talk about things, or the ability to lead people or a group toward a common goal or vision. Okay, yeah, those things I can see as part of executive presence. But I think that the term itself assumes that there's a best way or a way to do those things by exhibiting those traits in a certain way that might be easier for a neurotypical person or traits that might be more difficult for a neurodivergent person. So in practice, I've seen it used as a catch-all term to have something to coach to. Maybe you have an employee and they're doing great and you don't have anything else. You've got to think, ah, gee, I got to give them something. Executive presence. It's an easy go-to to have some opportunities to talk about, or maybe you have someone that you don't think is right for the next senior manager, director, VP role, whatever it is you're hiring for, you could say to yourself even, ah, executive presence. Maybe there's that certain it factor they don't have, and you lump that in with executive presence. But given all we've talked about on this series with ADHD, autism, any neurodivergence, that might impact how people are perceived as being able to be an executive. You might think to yourself, oh, he takes an extra minute to talk or to form his conclusions. Oh, that's executive presence. I just think it's a, I don't know. I think it's an outdated term and I'd much rather people focus on maybe the behaviors and the outcomes and the traditional umbrella of executive presence.
00:03:31 Flo: Yeah, and I think there are these two cousins terms I'm going to use. There's executive presence and executive maturity which for me are coded similar like the term culture fit what is a culture fit and a culture fit is supposed to mean as if an i'll use an example that i used recently with a client if an organization is a startup highly innovative moving very quickly someone who is a command and control leadership style wouldn't mesh well with a culture that because innovation startup moving quickly, that's more of entrepreneurial and a culture of empowerment, right? And those two wouldn't fit. And that makes sense to match your culture to your strategy, what you're trying to achieve. What I struggle with is using these terms like executive presence, executive maturity, and culture fit to really mean, oh, you're not like the rest of us. So we don't like you.
00:04:30 Andrew: Othering people.
00:04:30 Flo: Yeah, it's othering people. And I, this is what I struggle with that term, because it implies that to be appropriate, to be a leader, to have the presence that people may want to follow and may want to work with, that you have to be a certain way. And there is only one way.
00:04:55 Andrew: Yeah, it's basically saying we don't think you fit the stereotype of a leader. So what is that stereotype? Historically, it's straight white male that's like Jack Donaghy from 30 Rock, right? The guy well-groomed in a suit can convince you of anything. And if nothing, we've learned from this series, we've learned that everyone's just a little bit different and people have their different strengths and you do best when you work through your strengths, right? You don't you're not at your best when you're trying to change yourself. If it's someone else's image of you,
00:05:29 Flo: it is a complete waste of energy. And one of the things that I appreciate about the speed of technology is that let's look at the C-level leaders today. Their image today compared to the image of a C-level leader, say, 20, 30 years ago. It is so much more acceptable to wear a T-shirt or even, let's say, a button down shirt and nice jeans and sneakers and still be considered a leader. That's one of my favorite things out of the millennial generation is that.
00:06:04 Andrew: It's not even the millennials that are benefiting from that, right? Our company is a maverick. So our CEO is considered a maverick for the informal speeches and his informal dress. And a lot of that, they were tools that he was using to cultivate an image, but he was breaking the stereotype of what it meant to be a CEO to suit the brand that he was trying to build. But yeah, to your point, I think that technology and our generational differences and the different generations that are maybe more informal in their approaches or more open-minded to doing things differently has led to innovation and inclusion and creativity in the workplace. I love it.
00:06:49 Flo: Yes. And another scenario, another example that I want to use that I absolutely adore is someone who completely challenged, completely challenged what executive presence is supposed to be. And this is someone who is, in my opinion, in one of the least privileged categories. And Bozoma Saint John was, she has held, she is a force. She has held multiple C-level roles in big organizations like Netflix, Uber, like all these, these very big brands that have significant impact on our economy. And from the beginning, this Black woman has not shied away from wearing bright colors, very stylized fashion, not the gray and navy and black suits with the black pumps. No, she is just color and vibrant in how she dresses. And in every single video or any, I've never met her personally, but in every single video I've seen her in, you could tell that she brings an energy into the room. And that is the complete opposite of the suit and tie banker power suit situation that we see. And I love that about her. And I remember when I first learned about her several years ago, being inspired to, you know what? Maybe I don't need to tone down how I dress at work. And it is okay to wear my favorite MAC lipstick, Ruby Woo, which if MAC ever discontinues it, we're going to have a fight. And she challenges what executive presence is supposed to be. And I appreciate that. Yet, what we're still seeing in many workplaces is that there's still this expectation that is very narrow of what that leadership executive presence is supposed to be.
00:08:50 Andrew: Yeah, I almost think it's don't be too different because we don't want to make our shareholders or stakeholders uncomfortable. Don't be too different because you're going to make people feel bad. I think it's you don't want to make your stakeholders feel uncomfortable because there's someone in that position that they're not used to seeing.
00:09:10 Flo: I want to offer two assessments that I make, not based on research. These are my assessments, is that when someone pushes back to say, oh, this person lacks executive presence or executive maturity or culture fit or whatever. I think sometimes, probably more often than we would want to admit, that one of the problems is that the person whose way of being challenges the tradition of executive presence feels like a threat to the person whose career was made on maintaining that traditional executive presence.
00:09:51 Andrew: That makes sense to me, because if you think about it, the person that's usually giving someone else the feedback about executive presence is someone that's already a run or two above them on the corporate ladder. Right. So they've already lived through their experience and they've gone through jumping through the hoops to be seen as having that executive presence by their leaders before them. And I can see how they would filter their filter your development through their lens. Yeah.
00:10:20 Flo: And so it's like the executive presence version of saying, and I see this often with intergenerational conflict. So I had to work this hard. Why should the next person get it easier? I had to work this hard. Why are you expecting it to be easier for you? And it's holding someone to a standard to protect. It's holding someone else to a standard to protect their own hard work and investments and the value of the path that they took to achieve. Because if someone else bucks it, then it devalues. This is not my personal feeling, but I'm using myself as an illustration here. it's like saying if someone else does it different than me it devalues how hard I had to work and the path that I took to get to where I am so it's a threat
00:11:10 Andrew: yeah it's putting up walls around your own personal experience that you've had in the workplace and protecting that so that you can feel as important for getting where you've gone or as accomplished for getting there right yes and the person that you're giving this feedback to might have a completely different starting point or path in their life to get to where they're at. And by holding this is the standard by holding your own experience and your own hard work as the standard for that person to reach that next level, that just you're creating obstacles in their life that don't necessarily need to be there because this person could be a deliver you value that you might not even understand yet.
00:11:55 Flo: Exactly. It's just, to me, it's wild. The next assessment, again, my opinion, my assessment is also that when someone holds very closely to their definite, their traditional definition of executive presence, and another person comes along and challenges it, it might trigger in the first person, almost like, I wish I had done that. I wish I'd had the courage in my time to challenge. And in both scenarios, I believe the friction is about identity. When someone values their path to achieve whatever they have achieved and to see someone challenge it, it challenges identity. And that is really hard. But on the flip side, that is internal work that the person holding on to that traditional identity needs to do instead of taking the approach of trying to force neurodivergent people into the neurotypical, narrow definition of executive presence.
00:12:58 Andrew: Yeah, I see your point about the ego defense, because it's definitely so defensiveness and jealousy a little bit are the two ways that I would boil down what we just said, right?
00:13:10 Flo: I'm glad that you said jealousy, because that's the word that I had. And I held myself back. But you're right. That's exactly what I think it is.
00:13:18 Andrew: I think there's an element there too of emotional intelligence that I would expect of an executive. In today's modern world, my stereotype of an executive presence would include emotional intelligence, like being able to understand yourself and how you're different and that people are just different, right? So that's my ideal of somebody in an executive position would have strong emotional intelligence, but that defensiveness and that jealousy, and it might be, there might be a better word than defensiveness or jealousy. Those are emotions and there's thousands of words to describe different emotions, right? So maybe in your experience, you don't resonate with jealousy, but you might resonate with envy, right? Maybe that word resonates in your experience a little bit differently, but we're talking about the same things. It boils down to those same core feelings, right? Of defending something or wishing you had done something a different way. So I don't want to offend people if we're using the wrong word. Just if you don't identify with those words and you're questioning whether you're one of these leaders with executive presence, misconceptions or stereotypes stuck in your head, then I invite you to find your own word for it. But we're talking about not being able to get beyond allowing other people to experience the success that you've experienced a different way. and feeling envious or jealous or remorseful or whatever word you want to find.
00:14:47 Flo: It could be nostalgic.
00:14:48 Andrew: Yeah, exactly.
00:14:50 Flo: Nostalgic. The same way that someone might feel nostalgia for the days when everybody worked in the same exact location and email and DMs weren't an interruption all day because everything happened in person. holding on to that nostalgia that might be like a protection or defending nostalgia
00:15:12 Andrew: yeah and we're using a bunch of different words here but because people might experience this a little bit differently but the concept is there the concept is pretty universal isn't what we're talking about that's what i'm trying to convey right but it's nostalgia i like that one because it's a little more positive but it's another way of protecting that that same path right that we're trying to say hey, there's more than one path to get to the top. And you've got to do it in a way that's authentic and allow people behind you to do it in a way that's authentic to them. They don't have to follow exactly in your shadow,
00:15:49 Flo: right? The question is that what do we do when being aware of the differences in their workforce challenges us to expand our definition of what proper, I'm using air quotes, if you could see me, of proper executive presence. And I want to call back to the research of Sylvia Ann Hewlett, which is summarized in a beautiful article in Harvard Business Review. And in this article, she summarizes decades of research that presents how the meaning of executive presence has changed in decades. And there are three areas that she talks about that the rules essentially have changed. There's three pieces of components of executive presence that are still important, but how they're defined is different. And I'll start with the term gravitas, which sounds so dramatic, but that's basically the ability to have that kind of presence that people, I don't want to say command a room, but the kind of presence that people just trust, that steadiness, that's really important, especially in leadership and executive leadership. And in her research, she found that the old rule was like pedigree, what school you went to and all this other stuff, right? The new rule is executive presence, gravitas, being inclusiveness and respect, which is very different. it's not just where you went to school and did you go to an Ivy League school and all of that it's about respecting the people around you
00:17:39 Andrew: so to me I hear gravitas and I think it's about people being able to take you seriously and if I put it that way then I can see how that has changed over time because we are in a more inclusive world these days we have a podcast now about inclusivity and work for people that think differently right yeah i can see how if you have a leader who does not include people or is let's look at the opposite exclusive of groups who's gonna not everybody's gonna take that person seriously if they can't acknowledge that people think differently that people look differently they come from different backgrounds and places on earth and religion yeah they're not gonna be able to hold the room no one's going to follow them anywhere?
00:18:21 Flo: No. And like, if the way to command respect in the past, and I don't like that word command, that gravitas was based on pedigree today is based on extending respect and other people will respect you, which is very different. Another point that that is called out in this article is communication. And the communication is still very important. In the past, executive presence meant the strong speaking skills and the ability to command a room. Today, it's different because we're not always in a physical room. It is about being comfortable, even in a virtual room, and listening to learn, not just talking at people and expecting a sort of compliance, but being comfortable in person and digitally and listening to learn. And a word that I feel like it's played out, but it's important still is authenticity, being real in communication.
00:19:25 Andrew: absolutely yeah because i think if you're a successful communicator communications is about an exchange of feedback it's not about a one-way dialogue that you're giving to people to flow's point you said you also listen you're not just hearing people but you're absorbing what they're taking and you're listening so that you can adapt and you can mirror and you can and really understand. And often people are more prone to pay attention to the feedback or the information you're trying to exchange if they feel like you yourself are authentic, if you're coming from a place that's true to yourself. For some people, it's really easy to spot people when they're being fake, when they're not being authentic or true to themselves.
00:20:12 Flo: Yes. And this is what I that about this one. Communication, executive presence meant being able to command the room and people listen to you. The rules now are almost like you learn, learn, earning, not learning, almost like earning the right to be heard by making sure that you're listening to people.
00:20:34 Andrew: I like that.
00:20:35 Flo: I love that because it goes back to something that I've said before. The person with the most power takes the most risk. Now, this one is my favorite change. My favorite. Appearance is still important. It's still an important part of executive presence. But back in the day, it was polished, traditional, buttoned up and all of that. Now, it is about projecting realness, dressing for the new normal, just showing up in person. And yes, that includes online, having an online image. So maybe it's not about wearing a suit and tie all the time and the pencil skirt, but dressing for the situation. I'll use an example, which I'm so glad I know this. Andrew, you and I worked many late nights, overnights on product launches. How ridiculous would it have been for me to show up to a launch room at 11 p.m. to work from 11 p.m. to say 10 a.m. the next morning in a button down and a pencil skirt. That wouldn't even make sense. It's the middle of the night. We're wearing T-shirts and hoodies and jeans because we're there for a long shift overnight.
00:21:51 Andrew: Exactly. And you would definitely look out of place. There was a promotion we had when we launched at-home internet or at-home phone service and corporate communications team thought it would be fun to have everybody come to work in their pajamas or their bathrobes, and they forgot to specify to wear underwear. That became a little bit of an issue. So yeah, some people do need a little bit of coaching or clarity on what's appropriate in the workplace or what's appropriate to wear for their role. We're not saying that they don't. What we're saying, though, is that the norms have changed and what looks out of place and even between jobs, you might not have a bathrobe day at a bank, right? But if you have a more relaxed and formal workplace or your culture values individuality, you might have leaders that, hey, it's OK to wear a T-shirt and jeans to work. It's OK to maybe that's your business casual, whereas business casual, if you're a bank in front of customers, you might have to wear the khakis and still wear the polo shirt. Right. But be appropriate to the environment you're trying to create.
00:22:58 Flo: And to yourself. And which I love. And this is not to say, oh, you always have to dress down. I has in the only job that I've had where I consistently wore company gear was when I worked at a grocery store the only job and while I might have worn a company T-shirt here or there the way that I dress is really important to me and so to me it's part of self-expression so I usually wear whatever I want there one of my favorite things on Thursdays when I worked in a large organization was to wear poofy skirts, which does not sound like executive presence at all. But I used to wear like, would wear a T-shirt with a leather jacket and a really frilly, probably ridiculous skirt. But that was part of, that's part of my self-expression is part of what I enjoy. And it was a lot of fun for me. And I appreciate how the rules changing about executive, the expectations of executive presence have changed. The issue is that it's not just about what to wear, whether dressing up or down. It's about widening what fits into that definition. Because I think of someone who may be colorblind. And it's a very different type of ability. And how does the person who is colorblind, how are they expected to wear just certain things that fit a very narrow definition? Or maybe it's the person who is a little bit more adventurous and impulsive. Wearing a narrow selection of clothing or carrying themselves in a very narrow, acceptable way might feel so suffocating. And this is why that definition of executive presence needs to be widened to make room for people who think and move differently.
00:24:52 Andrew: Yeah. And I'm going to piggyback on that and give you the real world example of our time at VoiceStream and then T-Mobile and the leadership changes and how the culture changed along with it. So think back to the original CEO, there was Stanton and then Dotson, very business focused people. And that was, I know it was still casual, but the shadow that they were casting for the was, we're going to achieve these goals and be this company that are going to do things in a very structured way. And then when I left, so John Legere was still the CEO of the company. And when he came in, he is famously known for wearing the Magenta brand pretty much every day. Any picture of him through the time that he was CEO of T-Mobile, he was wearing something T-Mobile branded. usually a hoodie, sneakers, jeans, very casual, very much that young and social type of brand that we were going for as a company. But what that allowed to happen was that the atmosphere in the office, in the corporate office, down to our frontline call centers and stores became a little more informal. And people just felt more relaxed, I thought, in the workplace. place. We were very, we had goals and we had purpose and meaning and visions. And we knew what the strategy was, but we were able to bring ourselves to work like who we are and not a role that we were trying to play.
00:26:24 Flo: And I, one of the things that I appreciate about his leadership is that I remember I felt this, this sort of shake up in the very way that the company began the Ontario movement, he began an Uncarrier culture change that became more inclusive. And I appreciated that about Legere's leadership. The thing is, okay, so let's assume we all agree that executive presence is, the definition of executive presence needs to be widened to be more inclusive for people who think and move differently. There are cages that need to be made. And I'm going to start with how hard it is to challenge our biases, but how important that is. Like there are, there are just, it is so important for us to challenge the deeply held beliefs that we might hold that we're not even conscious of. Like going back to the examples that we talked about earlier, someone who sees someone who carries themselves or dresses differently and the other person's way of being challenges the first person definition of executive presence. That's a good opportunity to ask questions and get curious.
00:27:37 Andrew: Yeah. And I just want to jump in here because I want to spend another quick minute talking about biases because I know you and I have benefited from a lot of education and development courses on biases. but let's take this to the 30,000 foot view of a bias because you might think to yourself I'm not biased or I'm really good at being objective that's not exactly what we're talking about so there's no one that doesn't have an issue with bias you've got to consciously put an effort to overcome the biases that you have every decision you make throughout the day there's some sort of bias involved so there's a lot of work that goes into this so I challenge you to think about if you're listening think about maybe assumptions that you might make about people or things you might take for granted about something, a group of people or misconceptions that you might have. All of those are a form of bias. So I just wanted to unpack that a little bit more for our listeners.
00:28:33 Flo: And I do really, biases are, they're good and they're necessary. If we didn't have those mental shortcuts, every single thing in life would be really difficult because we would have to overthink every single decision. What we're talking about here are the biases that are unchecked and can lead to essentially misjudgments and misfiring. And it's important to, when there is a strong or even a subtle emotional reaction, that's an invitation to get curious. And ask yourself questions like, what value of mine is being challenged here by someone's way of being very different? or what are the expectations that I hold that maybe I haven't articulated? And are those expectations necessary and conducive to work? Are they even necessary for someone to be perceived or experienced as a leader? And are they even important or central to executive presence? And pay attention to your body. If your stomach tightens up, if you feel your breath getting a little faster, if you feel yourself getting hot in the ears, check in because it may be that there is an unnecessary, deeply held belief that is getting in the way of seeing someone as they truly are.
00:29:53 Andrew: Another thing to check the bias filter is if you jump to a conclusion very quickly, if you're if you are making a snap judgment, there's likely a bias involved. So take a moment to maybe pause and think through that. Am I coming to this conclusion because I have actual real evidence about this person in front of me? Or was it a snap judgment that you made because of a prior experience or something you've heard or maybe an expectation that you were held up to because your leader had that bias, right? So those quick moments, that can be a red flag.
00:30:30 Flo: Yes. So it's check when there's that, even if it's an orange flag, that's an opportunity to get curious.
00:30:36 Andrew: And that's an opportunity to learn. Yeah.
00:30:39 Flo: to learn.
00:30:40 Andrew: And the whole point about bias too, Flo, I think is an excellent one. And it kind of ties back to some of the things I said in our opening when you asked me about executive presence and what comes to mind for me. And that ties in because on one hand, I see the stereotype and I probably have a stereotype of what I think executive presence is too. And I have a bias because I have gotten feedback about executive presence. And part of me is I don't want you guys to think it's sour grapes. I'm complaining about executive presence because I was told I needed to work on executive presence. Right. We're talking about it because it can be confusing to people with a neurodivergence when you are not crystal clear on something or you're discussing a topic where your views that you might hold as consistent with everybody else's diverge from what the person might understand you to mean. and people with the neurodivergence might, it's entirely possible for them to be excellent leaders because of their problem solving and their empathy. And there's a whole host of traits that we've talked about that are strengths when it comes to neurodivergent thinking. But when you zero in on the different components that Flo mentioned, executive presence makes sense for those specific things and in the direction it is going. But what I think we don't like about that term executive presence, it's the bias and the stereotypes and the things that maybe are ingrained into you that you might not even be aware of, that you might not even be pausing to reflect on. So for leaders, I would say that it's important to use language that's more specific. So if you're giving someone feedback about how they can work on their development, become the manager, the director, VP, or whatever it is, and you're the person giving that feedback, don't use executive presence as a catch-all. What is it specifically that they need to work on that can help them with that gravitas or the inclusiveness, right? What is that key ingredient that they need to focus on? And that's important for a couple of reasons, but if you're using the catch-all executive presence, that's not clear or specific, and it can be confusing to them, and they might feel too embarrassed to follow up and ask questions. Like, what exactly do you mean? It can be demoralizing.
00:33:05 Flo: And it has to be actionable feedback. Like giving someone vague feedback is absolutely useless.
00:33:11 Andrew: Absolutely.
00:33:11 Flo: Getting specific. For example, if it's about communication, the feedback might be about being more succinct or using easier to understand language instead of technical jargon. But whatever it is, be specific in the feedback back that allows the other person and in partnership with you to brainstorm other ways of behaving or performing. But say you don't have executive presence, that's not even actionable. So it's absolutely pointless. Get specific.
00:33:40 Andrew: Yeah. And I would even offer also before you even give that feedback, ask questions. A very important component of coaching anybody is asking questions because you're not going to have a diagnosis of ADHD. Maybe they've chosen and disclosed to you. Maybe they haven't. Maybe they don't even realize that they have a neurodivergence or whatever. But if you notice that they are otherwise great, but they tend to go on too long with their written communications or over-explain things, ask questions to get to the why. Coach to self-discovery. Ask questions so that they understand the why because they probably might not understand the why also. And a good leader will do those things. I would also say that if you're giving feedback about executive presence, doesn't ask yourself if it even matters for the role does your stereotype assuming you have this stereotype of executive presence stuck in your head and it's the jack Donaghy or whatever your stereotype is for yourself does it matter that they look like that talk like that act like that to be able to lead the people that they need to lead
00:34:41 Flo: and also i might add to that are you maybe be holding on to the old definition of what was expected of a role? Does it matter to the current definition of what's expected? An example I'd like to use is the expectation of dressing conservatively several years ago, or was considered conservatively with muted colors and all of that. And maybe that was because that was a common social norm, it was important for building trust and relationships with stakeholders. In today's world, is that still necessary? Given what we just talked about earlier, what's more important is being approachable, authentic, dressing for the moment, for what the job calls for. It's important to chat. Am I holding on to a certain standard of executive presence based on what the job used to be? Or is it based on what the job requires for today's more complex, more uncertain, more inclusive, more digital world.
00:35:44 Andrew: Absolutely. And along those lines too, consider how you might change the environment to support the person. So that's what this whole podcast is about is building support scaffolding and tools and resources and knowledge and awareness around neurodivergent thinking and things that you can do to help yourself and others in the modern workplace. And if you're thinking of somebody that is not ticking those executive presence boxes for you, however you interpret them, think, is there something that you can do to match their work style or their processing modalities or whatever it might be that supports their ability to get to that next level? For example, if you have an employee that has dyscalculia, we talked about that in a prior episode, how can you change that environment to support that person with their issues with numbers and arithmetic and sequencing? I think as a leader, you could offer tools or resources or just support to not make that person feel less than in situations where they have to present or discuss numbers, give them opportunity to pause and make it a cultural norm to send any numbers and in advance of any meetings. Just a couple of quick examples.
00:37:05 Flo: Yes. And I also want to share a strategy for the person who receives that feedback. So maybe someone has said to you that you've got to work on your executive presence or your executive presence is lacking. I can imagine the feeling inside of someone making a statement that seems to address your identity. and it's totally natural to feel defensive and protective and holding space for those, giving yourself grace to experience those emotions. But if you get this feedback, I invite you to, before taking it to heart, take a breath to create some space and ask questions to get to the heart of the issue. The question might be, would you please tell me more about that? Please help me understand. Can you share an example of what you mean? getting really specific. It may be that the person may then share about a specific communication approach or way of handling a meeting or maybe holding back when the moment and it was an invitation to be bolder. Whatever it is, ask questions to get to the heart of the issue. And if you don't have specific feedback from that person, maybe begin to triangulate. Notice what other people are saying about you. And if there isn't corroborating evidence, that might tell you something about how seriously to take this feedback. And remember, feedback is a gift and not every gift needs to be kept.
00:38:40 Andrew: Yeah. And just filtering that through my ADHD lens real quick, because we talked about rejection sensitivity and taking feedback that might appear critical or like a personal attack. That might be how you feel in the moment when you're given that feedback and pause before you react. And Flo has said this before, but take a moment to feel in your body where you might be feeling that rejection or that pain that feedback is causing or confusion even. Just take a moment, live with that and see the feedback as the gift that it is.
00:39:12 Flo: Yes.
00:39:13 Andrew: But ask questions for sure if you don't understand anything.
00:39:15 Flo: Yeah, ask questions and hold it close, but not too close. And you have, we've explored so many angles about executive presence and starting with how sometimes it's a term used to cover up BS feedback. But it is important to talk about this, and I'm glad that we did. And as we wrap this episode of Different at Work, we've talked about, yes, executive presence, but then also different ways to approach that. For example, challenging your biases about what executive presence means because the rules have changed. For leaders, using language that is more specific instead of using executive presence or executive maturity as a catch-all. When giving feedback, ask about whether that feedback even matters for the job and consider how you might even change the environment to support a person whose way of being, neurodivergence doesn't fit in whatever the narrow definition of executive presence might be. And if you're the one receiving feedback, Take a breath and ask questions and protect your energy and don't take it to heart if it doesn't serve you. So thank you so much for joining us. This was such a great conversation and we hope that you keep being you, different at work.
00:40:37 Andrew: Hi, one final note. We are not mental health professionals and nothing you hear on this podcast is meant to replace therapy, diagnosis or professional care. We are just two people sharing what we've lived and learned. If today's episode brought something up for you or you're just looking for support, visit our website at DifferentAtWork.com for additional resources. Again, that's DifferentAtWork.com. Just click the resources tab. Goodbye.


